Toyota Prius Hybrid

46 mpg combined

Base price: $22,720

Our take: The perennial mpg all-star takes the crown again for 2009.

Honda Civic Hybrid

42 mpg combined

Base price: $24,320

Our take: Another top contender in reliability and fuel economy, the Honda Civic Hybrid is a smart choice.

Smart Fortwo Coupe

36 mpg combined

Base price: $12,635

Our take: This funky coupe is the least expensive on our list, proving you can be green without spending it.

Nissan Altima Hybrid

34 mpg combined

Base price: $27,345

Our take: The Altima Hybrid has the most interior space of the top five, wrapped in a tight package.

Volkswagen Jetta Diesel

34 mpg combined

Base price: $22,270

Our take: The Jetta is the only diesel drinker on our list, and reported mpg has been much higher.

Toyota Camry Hybrid

33 mpg combined

Base price: $26,870

Our take: Always a high-volume seller, the Camry has only increased its appeal with a hybrid version.

Ford Escape Hybrid

33 mpg combined

Base price: $30,370

Our take: The only SUV on our list, the Ford Escape hybrid does the work of truck with the economy of a Mini.

Toyota Yaris

32 mpg combined

Base price: $12,925

Our take: Offering a hatch for easy loading and a payment you can live with, the Yaris is green without announcing it to the world.

Mini Cooper

31 mpg combined

Base price: $19,200

Our take: Tops in the fun-to-drive category, the Mini Cooper’s 1.6-liter outperforms its volume by a mile.

Honda Fit

31 mpg combined

Base price: $15,420

Our take: Looking good in fun colors, the Honda Fit has fold-flat seats offering room for loads of cargo.

To read more visit the AutoWeek New car news, road tests, blogs, pix and expert insight section.